1. Start
  2. /
  3. Knowledge hub
  4. /
  5. To earth or not to earth, that is the question

Introduction

After countless forum discussions, phone calls from customers and lively debate, it is time to settle the earthing question once and for all. The question installers are faced with is whether a solar PV installation should be earthed.
Before we can delve into the key question, we need a basic understanding of some related topics and concepts.

Let us start by clarifying the different classes of electrical equipment. The paragraph below is copied from

the Swedish Electrical Safety Authority’s website:

  • Class I – Class I electrical equipment means that protection against electric shock is not based solely on basic insulation, but also on an additional safety measure whereby exposed conductive parts that can be touched are connected to earth.
  • Class II – Class II electrical equipment means that protection against electric shock is based on basic insulation and an additional safety measure, such as double insulation or reinforced insulation.

Before we reach the main subject, some concepts need to be explained:

  • Earthing – connecting an appliance to earth. This can involve both protective earth and functional earth.
  • PUS – Equipotential bonding bar. Usually refers to equipotential bonding, a collective term for protective bonding and functional bonding. A building may have several equipotential bonding bars, known as PUS bars. Each building may have only one main earthing terminal, which must be clearly labelled.
  • Functional earth (F-earth): Earthing to improve or ensure functionality. English: Functional Earth (FE)
  • PEN – Protective earth and neutral conductor. It must be a green-and-yellow conductor. English: Protective earth and neutral (PEN)
  • Stray current – An unwanted current that arises between points at different potentials, where the return current does not follow the metallic conductors intended for the return circuit. For example, between two earthing points, or between a water pipe and an earth electrode.

What does the standard say?

  • 421 Protection against fire The following clauses apply as additions:
  • 421.101 Protection against consequences resulting from insulation faults on the DC side where simple separation is used for the solar inverter on the AC side It is recommended that a fault be rectified as soon as possible.
  • 421.101.1 An insulation monitoring device (IMD) shall be installed to verify the insulation level on the DC side for as long as the solar array is in operation, except where clause 712.421.101.2 applies.
  • NOTE Insulation monitoring devices (IMDs) designed in accordance with SS-EN 61557-8 meet the above requirement.
  • The insulation monitoring device may be built into the inverter.
  • 421.101.2 Where a live conductor is functionally bonded inside the inverter on the DC side, measures shall be taken to ensure disconnection of the fault current in the event of an insulation fault to earth in accordance with Table 712.536.

What is to be achieved?

Insulation monitoring

As solar cells are Class II electrical equipment, the solar PV installation must be isolated from earth. This insulation resistance must be monitored continuously using an IMD (insulation monitoring device). This means that if the insulation resistance is too low, the inverter must issue a warning. The inverter usually has this function built in; if it does not, the installation must be supplemented with this function. In practice, the inverter measures the resistance between the strings (positive and negative) and earth. For this measurement to be possible, there must be an earth reference to measure against, as earth is at zero potential.

Arc fault detection

Arc fault detection, or arc fault current interruption (AFCI), is a function that is becoming increasingly common and is built into inverters. This functionality is already available, for example, in Huawei and SolarEdge inverters sold in Europe, while SMA and Fronius only offer it in their US models. In short, arc fault detection uses a sensor that analyses the DC circuit. Smart algorithms identify any arcs, and the inverter then throttles production, extinguishing the arc.

Reduced EMC issues

Functional earthing on an installation with optimisers reduces EMC (electromagnetic compatibility) issues. Earthing the rail system (which is connected to the optimisers) dampens high-frequency signals. Put very simply, functional earthing can be seen as acting like a shock absorber that “dampens” certain interference issues.

Is earth just earth?

From a purely installation-technical point of view, there is no difference between one earth and another. Functional earth may be taken from the protective earth terminal in the inverter. However, protective earth must not be taken from the functional earth cable. This is because that earthing does not protect against electric shock, for example by tripping a fuse. It must therefore not be called protective earth and must not be yellow-green.

Lightning protection?

If the property has a lightning protection system, or if there is a risk of induced interference, it is a good idea to consult a lightning protection professional about the design of such systems. Functional earthing, if carried out incorrectly, can contribute to an increased risk and render existing protection systems ineffective.

Different options for functional earthing:

Separate earth electrode

A separate earth electrode can be made using an iron rod or by burying a metal plate in the ground. The earth electrode is then connected to the roof by a DC cable. In practice, this means having a separate earth electrode for DC and AC.

Advantages:

  • Lightning strikes do not enter the property via consumer units or electrical appliances.
  • Reduced risk of stray DC reaching the protective earth/neutral from
  • the panel string/frame in the event of an insulation fault.

Disadvantages:

  • Expensive and time-consuming
  • Difficult to achieve a good earth with the right resistance (depending on the soil, moisture, etc.).

Connect the functional earth to the earth terminal where the other earths are connected

The functional earth is connected to the same earth terminal as the other earths (both protective earth and functional earth).

Advantages:

  • Simple connection and installation
  • Easy to know that the earth is good, as you use the house's earth.
     

Disadvantages:

Increased risk of induced voltage propagating into existing consumer units

Connect the functional earth to a separate earth terminal (separate from the protective earth)

The functional earth is connected to a separate earth terminal, but the terminal itself is connected to the same earth electrode. This is a compromise between options 1 and 2 listed above.

Advantages:

  • Simple connection and installation
  • Clear separation between protective and functional earth.
  • Easy to know that the earth is good, as you use the house's earth.
     
  • Disadvantages:
  • Increased risk of induced voltage propagating into existing consumer units

Conclusions

Having now read through this post, you will hopefully have gained even more knowledge and perhaps reached a greater consensus within the industry on the definitions and terms involved. As always with electrical installations, it is important to be familiar with the applicable standards and regulations. So make sure you have a good knowledge of these, while also checking what the inverter manufacturer actually requires for the installation.

Need help finding the right option?

We know it isn’t always easy to know which product or solution is best for you. Whether you have questions about our range, need guidance or want help finding a solution that suits your specific needs, we’re here for you. With our knowledge and experience, we’ll help you make the right choice.

Related posts

Technology blog

New rules for functional earthing

In a short time, functional earthing has gone from being a niche issue for particularly interested installers to becoming a central part of how solar installations should be designed, installed and inspected. With new shared guidelines and clarified pra...
Technology blog

Solar energy systems with open architecture – the flexible energy solution of the future

Solar energy has quickly become one of the most popular and effective solutions for producing sustainable energy. But as the technology develops, so too do the demands for flexibility, integration and future-proofing. A central concept in this developme...
Technology blog

The grid challenge – How the solar energy systems of the future can contribute to a stronger electricity grid

Sweden’s energy transition is well under way, and solar energy has become an integral part of the electricity system of the future. But the rapid growth in solar PV systems is placing new and unexpected demands on the electricity grid, particularly the...

This website uses cookies

Cookies ("cookies") consist of small text files. The text files contain data which is stored on your device. To be able to place some type of cookies we need your consent. We at Senergia AB, corporate identity number 556969-6023 use these types of cookies. To read more about which cookies we use and storage duration, click here to get to our cookiepolicy.

Manage your cookie-settings

Necessary cookies

Check to consent to the use of Necessary cookies
Necessary cookies are cookies that need to be placed for fundamental functions on the website to work. Fundamental functions are for instance cookies that are needed for you to use menus and navigate the website.

Statistical cookies

Check to consent to the use of Statistical cookies
To know how you interact with the website we place cookies to collect statistics. These cookies anonymize personal data.

Ad measurement cookies

Check to consent to the use of Ad measurement cookies
To be able to provide a better service and experience we place cookies to tailor marketing for you. Another purpose for this placement is to market products or services to you, give tailored offers or market and give recommendations on new concepts based on what you have bought from us previously.

Ad measurement user cookies

Check to consent to the use of Ad measurement user cookies
In order to show relevant ads we place cookies to tailor ads for you

Personalized ads cookies

Check to consent to the use of Personalized ads cookies
To show relevant and personal ads we place cookies to provide unique offers that are tailored to your user data